This article explains in detail some of the flaws behind eye witness testimony. Elizabeth thompson proved to be an extremely confident witness in the trial. Eyewitness testimony accuracy the typical methodological approach for studying testimony accuracy involves na. Eyewitnesses arent as reliable as you might think the. The claim that eyewitness testimony is reliable and accurate is testable, and the research is clear that eyewitness identification is vulnerable to distortion without the witnesss awareness. Frontiers predicting accuracy in eyewitness testimonies. Eyewitness testimony has an enormous impact on the outcome of a trial. Eyewitness testimony loftus 2019 applied cognitive. Indeed, many witnesses to an offence, both adults and children, can remember events with enough clarity and accuracy to assist triers of fact in rendering a verdict. Because eyewitness evidence is frequently the sole or primary evidence in a criminal case, the justice system needs to enhance the ability of judges, other legal professionals, and jurors to assess its accuracy. That iconic moment when a testifying witness points to the defendant as the.
Weve all experienced, at one time or another, our own memories failing us at times, and this may have been due to a number of factors. Legal versus cognitive explanations chapter pdf available december 2009 with 2,879 reads how we measure reads. First, we examine factors that influence disclosure. Discuss factors affecting the accuracy of eyewitness. Given the right conditions, these factors will influence how ones memory recalls the specific features. The court ruled that the trial judge should determine whether the questioning of the witness by the police was unnecessarily suggestive, and if it was, was it nevertheless reliable. There are many factors that need to be considered when assessing the accuracy of ones eyewitness testimony those factors are. In the legal system, eyewitness confidence is increasingly distrusted. Pdf the relation between consistency and accuracy of. We then turn to the topic of childrens eyewitness memory, particularly in children with histories of child maltreatment. Witnesses in both conditions made many changes to their previous reports by altering both initially correct and incorrect answers. Probably only a suspects signed confession can further convince a jury about that individuals guilt. In lieu of an abstract, below is the articles first paragraph. Eyewitness testimony should be admissible in court, but it should be admitted with caution and with an understanding that there are certain factors such as weapon focus and compromised memories which can reduce the reliability of eyewitness.
More specifically, the assumption that memory provides an accurate recording of experience, much like a video camera, is incorrect. Participants were male and female college students mean age 19. It refers to an account given by people of an event they have witnessed. Number of cases in which eyewitness testimony is a problem. Furthermore, a significant main effect of the completeness of eyewitness statements was found, but not for their accuracy. Participants were presented with a short video of a vehicle accident. Hundreds of more recent studies have explored the accuracy of eyewitness identifications. When judges and juries lack awareness of the factors that can affect the accuracy of eyewitness testimony, they can make mistakes. Factors affecting the accuracy of eyewitness identification. Although research on eyewitness testimony has attempted to determine memory accuracy and completeness in emotional events, the diversity of research methods used, the lack of uniformity in contents evaluated and the dierent tests utilized have hindered the elaboration of a coherent model. These factors include characteristics of the witness, characteristics of the witnessed event, characteristics of testimony, lineup content, lineup instructions, and methods of testing. Mar 12, 2019 the study of eyewitness testimony is thriving. Unfortunately, because it relies on human memory which if fallible, its use is highly problematic. Pdf how to analyze the accuracy of eyewitness testimony in a.
By changing a single word in nearly identical sentences, the effect of wording in an eye witness testimony can be examined. The vast majority of studies on eyewitness accuracy have focused on measuring and improving the accuracy of eyewitness identification, that is, witnesses ability to correctly recognize a perpetrator in a group of foils and suspects see wells et al. How to analyze the accuracy of eyewitness testimony in a criminal. A flawed eye witness testimony can be damaging to the lives of many innocent people that end up spending years of their lives behind bars and even the death row. This includes identification of perpetrators, details of the crime scene etc. In deciding the trustworthiness of eyewitness testimony, the u. Chad dodson, of the university of virginia, for one, says that academics in the field of general memory research have known for decades that under most conditions confidence is reliably associated with recognition accuracy. For example they may be required to give a description at a trial of a robbery or a road accident someone has seen.
Problems in using eyewitness testimony law teacher. The present study addresses this issue using a modification of the paradigm developed by loftus, miller, and bums 1978. Cassel and bjorklund 1995 examine age differences in suggestibility by comparing six and eightyearold children to adult college stu. Testing the accuracy of eyewitness testimony science project. In these studies on recognition judgments, a witness subjective confidence in hisher memory is the most. Pdf on jan 1, 2014, cara laney and others published eyewitness. However, after more than 30 years of eyewitnessidentification. Thus, any consideration of eyewitness testimony to jesus ministry also needs to include what might be termed earwitness testi mony. Indeed, many witnesses to an offence, both adults and children, can remember events with enough clarity and accuracy to assist triersoffact in rendering a verdict. Demand and the impact of leading questions on eyewitness. Loftus university of washington, seattle, washington 98195 and guido zanni new school for social research, new york, new york 10011 two experiments are reported in which subjects viewed a film of. Gustafsson pu, lindholm t and jonsson fu 2019 predicting accuracy in eyewitness testimonies with memory retrieval effort and confidence.
The credibility of eyewitness testimony has taken some hits from dna evidencebased refutation of memory. His main research focus is on eyewitness memory and identification, especially the determinants and predictors of both recognition and recall accuracy. One explanation for this low eyewitness accuracy is that it is due to demand characteristics created by the misleading questions. This strong faith in the adequacy of certainty as a. In 1967, for example, before most of this research, the supreme. Contemporary research on eyewitness testimony accuracy. This article describes a method for analyzing the accuracy of eyewitness testimony that will significantly enhance the ability of the criminal justice system to assess eyewitness accuracy. Over the last three decades, psychologists have made important discoveries, and applied those discoveries to the legal system in myriad ways. The reliability of eyewitness testimony eyewitness testimony is perhaps the oldest form of evidence and is typically given the most credibility in the courtroom other than a confession. The relationship between eyewitness confidence and. A significant main effect of negative emotion was found for the completeness of recall. Eyewitness testimony is historically among the most convincing forms of evidence in criminal trials e. How to analyze the accuracy of eyewitness testimony in a.
An experiment is reported in which the effect of cross. The influence of the wording of a question elizabeth f. The resulting technical working group for eyewitness evidence twgeyee established the first set of uniform practices for the collection and preservation of accurate and unbiased eyewitness evidence. There are factors that affect the accuracy of eyewitness testimony such as emotions, fundamental attribution bias, face recognition in other races, leading questions and many more. Analyses of recent and numerous dna exoneration cases reveal that mistaken eyewitness identification was involved in the vast majority of these convictions, accounting for. Loftus university of washington, seattle, washington 98195 and guido zanni new school for social research, new york, new york 10011 two experiments are reported in which subjects viewed a film of an automobile accident and then.
The relationship between eyewitness confidence and identification. Her testimony was compelling and convincing and undoubtedly aided jurors in finding. This project requires staging an event it can be as simple as having a visitor interrupt a class to ask the teacher a question, and then conducting a written survey to measure how. Eyewitness researchers have focused exclusively on the accuracy confidence relation between subjects, comparing the identification accuracy of confident witnesses to the accuracy of hes. Eyewitness testimony is used in a large number of cases and is responsible for many false convictions. First, ascertain whether law enforcement conducted the eyewitness interviews in a manner that obtained the maximum amount of information from the eyewitness. A method for analyzing the accuracy of eyewitness testimony. A very recent laboratory study has shown that juror perceptions of witness confidence account for 50% of the variance in juror judgments as to witness accuracy. A number of experts in the eyewitness testimony field say they generally support the new american psychologist paper. The completeness and accuracy of eyewitness recall across categories of detail were measured in experiment 1.
These practices are outlined in the document eyewitness evidence. Pdf eyewitness testimony and memory biases researchgate. In this project, you will compare the accuracy of eyewitness accounts of an event when subjects are questioned immediately after the event vs. A method for analyzing the accuracy of eyewitness testimony in. Along the way, there were disagreements, which were typically healthy in nature. Since jurors rarely regard eyewitness testimony with any skepticism, the expert testimony will increase the likelihood of this happening. The relation between consistency and accuracy of eyewitness testimony. One reason for these weak correlations is that confidence can be influenced independent of accuracy, for. The reliability if an eyewitness testimony is questionable. Pdf effects of interviewer word choice on eyewitness. Eyewitness testimony is perhaps the oldest form of evidence and is typically given the.
The relation between consistency and accuracy of eyewitness testimony 129 accuracy of each of the four response categories consistent, contradiction, reminiscent, and forgotten in addition to. Perhaps the issue at hand was not important to us at the time, and. This study examined the effect of the wording of interview questions on eyewitness testimony. For example, the state of new jersey recently adopted jury instructions declaring that although some research has found that highly confident witnesses are more likely to make accurate identifications, eyewitness confidence is generally an unreliable indicator of accuracy new jersey courts, 2012a. The basic distinction these researchers have made is between system variables, factors the legal system can control, and estimator variables, factors the legal system cannot control. The witness may be so certain that the person that thy are pointing out is one hundred per cent the suspect or they could be so certain when it comes to retelling the incident, although these people are so sure on what it is they are doing, their testimony cannot always accurate. Jennifer thompson, then a 22yearold college student, had gone to bed early in her offcampus apartment. Both the discrimination and the overbelief rationales make two fundamental claims. The reliability of eyewitness testimony semantic scholar. Semantic scholar extracted view of how to analyze the accuracy of eyewitness testimony in a criminal case by richard a. In the united states, approximately 75,000 defendants are implicated by eyewitnesses annually department of justice, 1999.
Next, determine whether the identification procedures in the case were fair and unbiased finally, evaluate what eyewitness factors during the crime are likely to have increased or decreased the accuracy of the eyewitness testimony. Kebbell and wagstaff 1997a suggest that the three principal reasons for eyewitness testimony are. Janet reno stated in her report to the federal government that 26 of the first 28 exonerations were caused by errors in eyewitness recall. The accuracy of eye witness testimony and its flaws. Many factors influence the accuracy of recall and identity of a face, some of which we have little to no control.
498 1547 421 810 399 72 1330 1470 1165 166 454 1042 994 941 667 278 1181 384 40 548 857 1170 941 194 403 1061 569 25 1437 1243 1385 1157